The Parishes of St Giles and St Philip and St James with St Margaret

  St Margaret's Church

SIGNS AND WONDERS at St Margaret's Church, Oxford

 

 
 
 
 
 
 
 

St Margaret's church may not have bats in its belfry, but it does have pelicans on its font cover. Actually, I'm not quite sure what they're doing there.  They enact a scene from medieval literature in which an adult bird revives its young by piercing its own breast and feeding them with its blood.  In religious art, this story serves as an allegory of self-sacrifice; that's whv we find other pelicans on our All Souls altar, which is a war memorial.  Why have them on the font cover, though?  I've been exploring such issues for some while now.  St Margaret's contains a wealth of symbolism, most of it decipherable. Basic identification, however, can be merely the first step in working out why a certain image has been utilized, and this is very much a "work in progress" report with as many questions as conclusions.
 

The Font cover

The altar in All Souls Chapel

The various figures and symbols around the church can, of course, have a range of meanings and values from the devotional to the plain curious.  One of my personal objectives in this project has been to explore what collective messages they might be presenting to us.  It's certainly possible to identify a few common strands.  One is what I call the "medieval" theme. This is the Victorian ecclesiological formula which gives St Margaret's much of its character, a watered-down vision of an English church prior to the Reformation.  The rood screen and the stone guardian angels up above the high alter reredos are part and parcel of a building designed to look as though it evolved over several hundred years, from mock-Norman font to fake late-medieval font cover.  Allied to this, and equally symptomatic of the parish's Anglo-Catholic roots, are the images and symbols of the Virgin Mary which permeate the church, appearing in almost all of the windows and much of the  woodwork.  (How many people, like me, assumed that all those "M"s stood for "Margaret"?)
Another strand which has emerged through the identification process is a little more surprising.  If this is a "medieval" church, then it's also a decidedly British one.  At least sixteen of the saints depicted here are either British, or associated with the Church here.  To name but a few, we have St Alban, St Augustine of Canterbury (along with St Gregory the Great who sent him) and St Margaret of Scotland, besides more borderline figures such as St Helen and St George.  At least some of this emphasis is intentional.  The greatest concentration of these saints is in the clerestory windows, which are all of near-identical design, and must, I think, have been planned as a group.  On one side we have bishops such as Saints Hugh and Chad, whose authority embraced the Oxford area; on the other side are a rather mixed bag including St Edward the Confessor, whose common factor seems to be royal status.  Monarchs and bishops: how very Anglican.  To this group we should probably also add the window in the chancel to St John the Baptist and St Bernard, patrons of our secular patron, St John's College.

Beyond this, though, there is little obvious sense of schemes of symbolism.  There is, admittedly, a curious consistence to the Biblical images in the church.  The main examples are the three southerly windows in the Lady Chapel, which were designed as a group to present the story of our redemption.  The incidents included run from the Annunciation to Pentecost, and in fact there's scarcely another image in St Margaret's which adds to this sequence.  The Old Testament is represented only by the Flood, and by the kings, priests and prophets who appear in the main east window as Christ's forefathers and foretellers. There are no scenes from the Early Church, and just few fleeting references to the glory of God as portrayed in Revelation.  No Fall, then, and no Judgement, except by implication.  In this at least, the medieval church is left behind.

The rest is an odd mixture.  Our St Catherine window can be accounted for as a memorial to Catherine Fordyce Birch.  No such clues are forthcoming, however, about the origins of the nearby St Nicholas window.  Nevertheless, the greatest mystery is generated by one of our most prominent fixtures, the high altar reredos.  The central panel here includes the Epiphany, the Crown of Thorns, the four great Doctors of the Western Church (Augustine, Gregory, Ambrose and Jerome), Saints Frideswide and Margaret of Antioch (our patron), and a frieze of the True Vine.  I have my own ideas about possible interpretations, but I'd be interested to hear what other people think.*  Similarly, if anyone can identify the flanking saints on the All Souls and Lady Chapel reredoses, or the soldier-saint on the Edgar Hester memorial, please do let me know. 
We are most grateful to Paul Hunneyball whose copyright this article is, for allowing us to print it on the St Margaret's Church website.

 
 
 
 
 
 
* Comments may be sent to ben.simpson@wolfson.ox.ac.uk who will relay them on.

Home

St Margaret's Church
on the Internet


 Vicar: Andrew Bunch